Broker comparison

comdirect vs.
S Broker

Which broker fits your needs?

Platforms, products and fees side by side.

Updated: October 2026

See comparison

Summary

Your goal decides.

comdirect has a higher rating of 4.4/5 compared to S Broker (3.8/5). comdirect has been in the market since 1994, making it the more experienced provider. Execution speed: comdirect ~30 ms (Xetra), ~80 ms (Tradegate), S Broker ~50 ms (Xetra/Tradegate).

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group

At a glance

The key differences

Criterion
Platformscomdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTraderS Broker App, S Broker Web, Marktinvestor pro
Product typesStocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, DerivativesStocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives
Options tradingYes, Eurex options trading availableYes, Eurex trading available
Fee model€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)€4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99)
Minimum deposit0 €0 €
RegulationBaFinBaFin
More informationDetailsDetails

Platforms

comdirect

comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader

S Broker

S Broker App, S Broker Web, Marktinvestor pro

Product types

comdirect

Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives

S Broker

Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives

Options trading

comdirect

Yes, Eurex options trading available

S Broker

Yes, Eurex trading available

Fee model

comdirect

€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)

S Broker

€4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99)

Minimum deposit

comdirect

0 €

S Broker

0 €

Regulation

comdirect

BaFin

S Broker

BaFin

More information

comdirect

Details

S Broker

Details

Product access and costs depend on market, account and permissions.

Detailed comparison

Comparing fees

Compare total costs, not just the order fee.

€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)

Published fee
€4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90)
Minimum deposit
0 €
See terms at provider

€4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99)

Published fee
€4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99)
Minimum deposit
0 €
See terms at provider

The relevant costs depend on market, currency, order size and trading style.

Execution quality

Order type, venue and liquidity affect execution.

Check the provider’s execution policy and available order types for your account.

Provider information

Check the provider’s execution policy and available order types for your account.

Provider information

Product range

StocksETFsOptionsFuturesFundsBondsDerivatives
StocksETFsOptionsFuturesFundsBondsDerivatives

Categories come from broker profiles. Check specific markets and permissions before deciding.

Trading platforms

comdirect App · comdirect Web · ProTrader

comdirect offers three trading platforms: The comdirect App enables mobile trading with real-time prices, watchlists, and quick order placement. The comdirect Web platform provides comprehensive chart analysis, market data, and detailed order masks. ProTrader is aimed at active traders and offers professional charting tools, Level 2 order book, technical indicators, and advanced order types. All platforms support trading at numerous exchanges and provide access to the Eurex derivatives market.

Explore platform

S Broker App · S Broker Web · Marktinvestor pro

S Broker offers three trading platforms: The S Broker App enables mobile trading with price alerts and quick order placement. The S Broker Web platform provides comprehensive market data, chart analysis, and portfolio overview. Marktinvestor pro is the professional platform for active traders, offering real-time prices, technical analysis, customizable chart layouts, and an extended order book. All platforms support Eurex trading and various order types.

Explore platform

Regulation & security

Regulation does not prevent market losses. The relevant authority depends on the contracting entity.

Your investor profile

Who might it suit?

Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading

  • Eurex options trading available
  • Full bank with checking account
  • Comprehensive educational resources
  • Higher fees than neobrokers
  • Custody fee without activity

The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group

  • Sparkassen security and trust
  • Eurex options trading available
  • Wide product range
  • Higher fees than neobrokers
  • Custody fee without activity

Find the broker that fits

comdirect oder S Broker?

Side by side. Decided with knowledge.

See the differences that matter, and the Academy lessons that explain them.

comdirect4.4
  • Eurex options trading available
  • Full bank with checking account
  • Comprehensive educational resources
S Broker3.8
  • Sparkassen security and trust
  • Eurex options trading available
  • Wide product range
VS
  • Fees
  • Platform
  • Regulation
  • Matching lessons
Two brokers. Many options. Your call.
Open The Dealing Room

Your questions

Frequently asked questions

How do fees differ between comdirect and S Broker?
comdirect: €4.90 base fee + 0.25% of order volume (min. €9.90). S Broker: €4.99 + 0.25% of order volume (min. €8.99, max. €54.99). Compare total costs for the specific market, product, currency and order size in the current fee schedule.
Which broker offers more products: comdirect or S Broker?
comdirect offers Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives. S Broker offers Stocks, ETFs, Options, Futures, Funds, Bonds, Derivatives.
How are comdirect and S Broker regulated?
The broker profiles list BaFin for comdirect and BaFin for S Broker. Your account's contracting entity determines the applicable oversight and protection rules; check its current disclosures.
Is comdirect or S Broker better for beginners?
comdirect lists a 0 € minimum deposit and offers comdirect App, comdirect Web, ProTrader. S Broker lists 0 € and offers S Broker App, S Broker Web, Marktinvestor pro. Compare usability, available products and costs for your intended use.
comdirect vs S Broker: Which broker is better overall?
The choice between comdirect (4.4/5, 1800 reviews) and S Broker (3.8/5, 620 reviews) depends on your needs. comdirect: Direct bank with comprehensive securities and options trading. S Broker: The online broker of the Sparkassen financial group.

Your next step

Your next step

Keep comparing

More broker comparisons

Keep learning

Before you pick a broker

The guides worth reading before your first trade, whichever of the two you choose.

Options taxes in GermanyFlat-rate tax, loss offsetting and allowances.Options trading basicsStrike, expiry, underlying: the building blocks of every option.Regulation: BaFin, ESMA & investor protectionWho supervises your broker and what that protects.
Terms in the glossary:PremiumCall optionMarginExercisePut option